IMPs. Both vulnerable.
♠A 6 ♥A Q J 10 5 ♦ — ♣K 10 9 8 6 4
| West | North | East | South |
| 1♠ | 5♦ | ? |
| 5♥ | 5♠ | 5NT | ||
| 6♣ | 6♦ | 6♥ | 6♠ | 6NT |
| 7♣ | 7♦ | 7♥ | 7♠ | 7NT |
| Pass | Dbl |
What’s your call?
For yesterday’s It’s Your Call deal (from June 2010’s Bridge Bulletin), 5NT was named top bid.
Partner opens the bidding, your right-hand opponent bids your void at the five level and you have a strong hand with the other two suits. Now what? The majority bid 5NT — pick a slam.
“5NT,” said Kerri Sanborn. “I’ll take a chance and force to slam. This is the only way to get us to the right strain.”
“5NT, pick a slam,” said Barry Rigal. “Anyone who tells you that they have any idea what’s right, should be kicked off the panel. A few might resign, mind you, rather than answer this one!”
“Yes, we could be cold for a grand slam,” said Brad Theurer, “but East’s preempt has robbed us of too much bidding space, so I’ll bid 5NT and settle for getting (hopefully) to the best strain. Partner should not read this as grand slam force. There are more hands where this bid is needed as pick a slam, as is the case here.”
“5NT is pick a slam,” said Jeff Meckstroth. “Who is coming up with these problems?”
“We expect partner to get the 5NT as pick-a-slam bid,” said Linda and Robb Gordon. “It’s much more useful than the old grand slam force. Double could be right, but we are odds-on to have at least a small slam. Partner would likely pass a double.”
“I hope partner can work out that 5NT is pick a slam,” said Karen Walker. “I can’t justify settling for plus 200 or plus 500 when I’m so certain we have a slam somewhere.”
“I don’t think partner will mistake 5NT for grand slam force,” said Allan Falk. “Double hardly describes this hand when I want to be in slam somewhere.”
There’s a comedian in every crowd: “5NT,” said Steve Robinson. “This is choice of suits. Let partner guess.”
Six experts chose double.
“Double shows values and no clear-cut action,” said Kay and Randy Joyce.
“I suspect we have a better contract than 5*D* doubled,” said August Boehm, “but I see no reliable way to guess what it is. Once in a while, partner can take it out, and then we’re in good shape.”
“I really don’t like double,” said Larry Cohen, “but I can’t see guessing to bid 5♥ or 6♣. In my dreams, partner pulls the double, but in real life, he will probably pass, and I have done the wrong thing.”
Two experts saw the danger of double, but didn’t want to commit to slam.
“I must bid, but what?” asked Don Stack. “I would bid 5NT if I thought partner would choose between hearts and clubs, but it should probably show a stronger spade tolerance. I will opt for the reasonable guess of 5♥.”
“5♥,” agreed Betty Ann Kennedy. “The power of preempts has struck again.”
“This is more fantasy,” said Mike Lawrence. “I will guess to bid 6♣. I would bid 5NT if I was sure it was some kind of pick a slam.”
Which bid has a higher frequency after a preempt: the grand slam force or pick a slam? The panel felt using the bid as showing two suits occurs more often, and, therefore, is more useful.
Want to receive the retro “It’s Your Call” by email?
Click here to subscribe.